Contents
A Derby to Remember for All the Wrong Reasons
In a match that will go down in Manchester derby history, Manchester United fans found a surprising source of joy amidst their team’s rollercoaster performance: Matheus Nunes. The Manchester City midfielder’s unfortunate blunders during the game led to a rather ironic twist, as he was voted man of the match despite his glaring mistakes.
City’s Defensive Woes on Full Display
Starting at left-back for Pep Guardiola’s side, Nunes had a game to forget. With City leading 1-0, he made a catastrophic back-pass intended for goalkeeper Ederson, which was intercepted by United’s Amad Diallo. Nunes sprinted back in a desperate attempt to rectify his error but ended up fouling Diallo, conceding a penalty that Bruno Fernandes coolly converted.
As if that wasn’t enough, Nunes was inches away from preventing Diallo’s dramatic last-minute winner, falling just short of clearing the ball off the line. The BBC’s player ratings reflected the fans’ sentiments, as Nunes was voted man of the match with a score of 9.21, while his teammates barely scraped past the 5/10 mark.
Frustration Boils Over for City Players
Bernardo Silva, visibly frustrated, expressed his disappointment post-match, highlighting the need for accountability. “We deserved what happened,” he stated. “At this level, a game or two is unlucky. Ten games? That’s not about luck.” Silva pointed out that poor decisions in crucial moments cost them dearly, particularly in a heated derby. “Minute 87, winning 1-0, and our corner ends in a penalty for them. You can’t make stupid decisions like that,” he added, reflecting the collective frustration within the City camp.

Amad Diallo’s Heroics Steal the Show
Despite the chaos, Amad Diallo emerged as the real hero of the day. He won the penalty that brought United level and then capped off a remarkable performance with a stunning winner deep into injury time. Flicking the ball past Ederson, Diallo secured the victory for United, turning the tide of the match in spectacular fashion.
Player Ratings: Who Shone and Who Floundered?
In the aftermath of the derby, player ratings reflected the contrasting fortunes of both teams. Here’s how some of the United players fared:
- Andre Onana – 6: Did not inspire confidence but wasn’t heavily tested.
- Lisandro Martinez – 7: A calming presence and instrumental in setting up the winner.
- Harry Maguire – 8: Dominated his battle with Erling Haaland, proving his worth in a high-stakes match.
- Bruno Fernandes – 8: Missed a chance but remained composed during the penalty.
- Amad Diallo – 9: A standout performance culminating in a memorable derby winner.
On the other hand, Nunes’ performance was a stark contrast to his teammates, who averaged under 5/10, highlighting the defensive frailties that have plagued City in recent weeks.
A Season of Struggles for Manchester City
With this latest defeat, City finds itself in a troubling run of form, managing just one win in their last eleven games. The frustration among players and fans alike is palpable, as they grapple with the reality of their current situation.

Looking Ahead: What’s Next for Both Teams?
As Manchester United celebrates a crucial victory, they will be looking to build on this momentum. Meanwhile, Manchester City must regroup and reflect on their mistakes if they hope to turn their season around. The derby may have ended in triumph for United, but the lingering questions about City’s performance will undoubtedly fuel discussions in the weeks to come.

